Persuasion
Thursday, April 26, 2012
The Right Technology May Be a Pencil
The Right Technology May Be a Pencil
Mary Beth Hertz (@mbteach on Twitter) is an elementary computer teacher in Philadelphia, PA and a regular blogger on Edutopia. You can read more of her work on her own blog at Philly-teacher.
Mary Beth Hertz (@mbteach on Twitter) is an elementary computer teacher in Philadelphia, PA and a regular blogger on Edutopia. You can read more of her work on her own blog at Philly-teacher.
As a tech integration
specialist and a computer lab teacher, one can imagine that I have a special
place in my heart for bringing current technologies into the classroom. At the
same time, I find that sometimes pencil and paper do just as good of a job.
It's important to remember
that sometimes just because we have access to new technologies does not mean
that older technologies won't suffice. Too often we get so excited by the fancy
gadgets that we have access to that we forget that sometimes a pencil and paper
will suffice.
For example, my friend Karen McMillan teaches blogging with her
middle schoolers by having them write using pencil and paper first. Karen has
her students write paper blog posts and then has them leave comments in analog
format in preparation for their "real" blogging experiences using
Google Sites. As Karen told me on Twitter, "It helps them visualize
blogging in a medium that they are more comfortable with. Plus... it's fun!"
In my lab, students receive
a folder for each project with a project overview, rubric and templates.
Technically I could host all of that online, but when managing a project,
having the paper there really is just more functional and effective. Perhaps if
I was in a 1:1 setting things might be different, but with 45 minutes twice a
week, paper is just the easiest way to share an make information easily
accessible. In addition, I often have students plan their ideas out on paper
before they attempt it on the computer. Often, when transferring skills, this
makes it easier for students to successfully complete a complex project.
Paper and pencil also lends
itself to exit slips, as Jen Roberts suggested to me on Twitter. While
I sometimes have the exit ticket completed online, I also use checklists as a
form of exit ticket. Other teachers in my building use exit tickets to quickly
assess who feels comfortable with the material from the class period or from a
particular lesson. Sometimes, too, having students fill out a paper and pencil
Venn Diagram to compare and contrast and then discuss a topic is powerful and
requires only the technologies of pencil and paper.
This is important to
remember: At one time, pencils and paper were a kind of technology. My friend John Spencer's brilliantly funny and poignant
book, Pencil Me In,
follows that trajectory. His main character is a "pencil integrator"
and is working hard to give his students access to this new technology, often
to the chagrin of his colleagues. Through this metaphor, Spencer describes the
journey that Tom takes and how he discovers that as much as he loves the bright
and shiny new pencils, sometimes chalk slates do the trick just fine.
It is not so much about the
tool and what it can do, but more about the purpose for using the tool. Obviously,
if students want to share pictures of a project they are working on, a digital
camera and a blog make a lot more sense than a flipbook. Still, don't count out
older technologies just because you are trying to be a "21st Century
Educator." Sometimes a dry erase marker and a wipe-off slate will do the
job just fine.
Laptop Information
If our school were to purchase a new set of laptops next year, Mr. Billings has confirmed that we would purchase the MacBook Pro with an adjusted price of $1,120.00 per laptop.
Please see the link below for more specific information.
http://www.apple.com/macbookpro/
Please see the link below for more specific information.
http://www.apple.com/macbookpro/
iPad Information
If our school were to purchase a new set of iPads next year, Mr.
Billings has confirmed that we would purchase the iPad 2 which has wi-fi capability. The price is $399.00 per iPad.
We would also purchase a "Smart Cover" for each iPad, which each start at $39.00.
Last of all, we would look into getting keyboards, but it is not guaranteed. Total price = $69.00
http://store.apple.com/us/product/MC184
Please see the link below for more specific information.
http://www.apple.com/ipad/
We would also purchase a "Smart Cover" for each iPad, which each start at $39.00.
Last of all, we would look into getting keyboards, but it is not guaranteed. Total price = $69.00
http://store.apple.com/us/product/MC184
Please see the link below for more specific information.
http://www.apple.com/ipad/
Tuesday, April 24, 2012
Reading Teacher Journal Article
Advantages
and Considerations of Using iPads for Literacy Instruction
Helpful Aspects of iPads for
Instruction
|
Special Considerations for using iPads in
Instruction
|
Students were able to apply their prior knowledge of
other digital literacy tools to figure out how to navigate the iPad without a
lot of instruction from the teacher.
|
Manipulation was difficult within some of the apps.
For example, it was sometimes difficult to resize text and images.
|
When they encountered problems, students worked
collaboratively to figure out how to navigate the iPad. This collaboration
led to increased and improved conversations about the assignments during the
learning experiences.
|
The teacher had to rethink how she wanted students
to save and share their work.
Though not difficult, the teacher had to adjust to a new way of
receiving and reviewing student work.
|
The availability of many different apps, as well as
the many features of each app, made it easy to differentiate assignments for
students.
|
The sensitive touch screen caused students to engage
functions unintentionally. For example, a student accidentally engaged the
highlighting function in iBooks when using his finger to track along with the
text he was reading.
|
iPads power on and off quickly, so it was quick and
easy to restart iPads when needed without disrupting the learning experience.
|
As with any digital technology, teachers had to
troubleshoot at times. This reality required the teacher to have a
willingness to explore the potential causes of problems that arose.
|
Because individual apps perform specific functions,
and because iPads are easily stored in student desks, it was common for the
teacher to spontaneously think of ways to integrate the iPads.
|
Creating word documents is possible, but the apps
that make it possible have limited features. For example, there is no app
that allows the user to track changes within a document.
|
The iPad can be programmed to display in many
different languages.
|
Many iPad apps do not allow the user to edit work
once it has been saved.
|
Monday, April 23, 2012
Writing- Is it ethical to eat meat? (NY Times)
NY Times The Learning Network
Example responses:
I think it is okay to eat meat. Yes I do eat meat, and I think that the way people obtain meat is fine. If people do not want to eat meat I have nothing against what they may believe. I do know some people who are vegetarians or vegans. Meat is important because it is very high in protein, but there are many other foods that also have protein, for those who may not eat meat.
— Faith B
I think it is fine to eat meat. Although I don’t agree with processed meat… I don’t know if i could use McDonalds as an example but they use the processed pink slime which to me sounds disgusting so I’m never going to eat food at McDonalds again. I do know people that are vegetarians. I think having meat in your diet is much more healthy than not. It gives you the nutrients necessary where as vegetarians take vitamins to get those nutrients.
— Tristan M
Yes, I kinda do think it’s okay. Yes, I do eat meat. Yes, there should be because they do some things that are cruel to them. No, I don’t really think I do. I really think that people would be better off without it because they would have a more healthy diet. I would say, “I like meat, but I also like other things, and people would really be better without meat. Then again well, we do need a little meat not a whole lot though.”
— Shanta
Example responses:
I think it is okay to eat meat. Yes I do eat meat, and I think that the way people obtain meat is fine. If people do not want to eat meat I have nothing against what they may believe. I do know some people who are vegetarians or vegans. Meat is important because it is very high in protein, but there are many other foods that also have protein, for those who may not eat meat.
— Faith B
I think it is fine to eat meat. Although I don’t agree with processed meat… I don’t know if i could use McDonalds as an example but they use the processed pink slime which to me sounds disgusting so I’m never going to eat food at McDonalds again. I do know people that are vegetarians. I think having meat in your diet is much more healthy than not. It gives you the nutrients necessary where as vegetarians take vitamins to get those nutrients.
— Tristan M
Yes, I kinda do think it’s okay. Yes, I do eat meat. Yes, there should be because they do some things that are cruel to them. No, I don’t really think I do. I really think that people would be better off without it because they would have a more healthy diet. I would say, “I like meat, but I also like other things, and people would really be better without meat. Then again well, we do need a little meat not a whole lot though.”
— Shanta
Writing-Hair Loss
If you are losing your hair, you are losing your social life. Get it back with HAIR RETURN. Comb Hair Return through your hair each morning and in 7 days you will have a full head of hair. Guaranteed!
Writing-Political Ad
Marguerite Evans will look out for the family farms. No one will be left out in the cold. She will bring many federal projects and many jobs to the area. Vote for Marguerite Evans for Governor and you’ll get a better future.
Writing-Swordfish
Americans are hooked on swordfish! But last month 27 top restaurant chefs took them off the menu.
Why? The number of swordfish is shrinking fast, and chefs want to save the tasty fish. During the 1960s, fishermen switched from using harpoons to using long lines with hundreds of hooks. Result: many more small swordfish are caught. The small fish never get a chance to grow and produce more fish.
Lisa Speer, an environmentalist, says it's time to give swordfish a break "so future generations can enjoy them."
Why? The number of swordfish is shrinking fast, and chefs want to save the tasty fish. During the 1960s, fishermen switched from using harpoons to using long lines with hundreds of hooks. Result: many more small swordfish are caught. The small fish never get a chance to grow and produce more fish.
Lisa Speer, an environmentalist, says it's time to give swordfish a break "so future generations can enjoy them."
Writing-Helmet Laws
Helmet laws are meant to save kids from the
head injuries caused by bike accidents. Unlike a
bruise or a scrape, a head injury can take many
years to heal. A serious head injury can kill you.
Simon Crider, 11, knows how important a
helmet can be. Two years ago, he was riding his
bike near his house in Gainesville, Florida,
when he hit a rock and fell. His helmet cracked
when he hit the ground, but it protected his
head.
head injuries caused by bike accidents. Unlike a
bruise or a scrape, a head injury can take many
years to heal. A serious head injury can kill you.
Simon Crider, 11, knows how important a
helmet can be. Two years ago, he was riding his
bike near his house in Gainesville, Florida,
when he hit a rock and fell. His helmet cracked
when he hit the ground, but it protected his
head.
Sunday, April 22, 2012
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)